Electric cars 2023: In some parts of the U.S., recharging now more costly than filling up

This is how a lot electrical energy costs have surged in components of New England this winter: For some drivers of electrical autos and hybrid automobiles, it is now costlier to cost up than to refill.

Energy charges throughout the area have jumped a median of 30% since final summer season, whereas gasoline costs have receded effectively beneath their peak in June of 2022. Internet engineer Matt Cain, who lives in Amherst, Massachusetts, stated he ran a value comparability when his electrical energy invoice shot up in January and located that his general prices for utilities had climbed a whopping 50%.

“We’ve got a Prius Prime that we usually drive round city, and we drive most of it on electrical energy. It is now 50% costlier than fueling it with fuel,” he advised CBS MoneyWatch. 

Cain stated the worth hike hasn’t modified his driving habits. However it has prompted his spouse, who works at a local people faculty, to cost the automobile at work the place it is cheaper. “It isn’t a degree of ache for me, however it’s one thing I’ve seen,” he stated.

On Reddit, different EV house owners have famous the rising recharging prices. One Massachusetts resident stated their energy firm, Nationwide Grid, jacked up native electrical energy costs to 44 cents per kilowatt-hour — 3 times the nationwide common.

“We’re in just about the identical boat in [New Hampshire] and it sucks,” stated one other person. “Went from a median of $220 a month electrical invoice… to now near $400 a month and thats with off peak charging, and its imagined to go up once more considerably in February.” The speed hike pushed the person to enroll in a photo voltaic array, with a month-to-month invoice round half their present energy invoice, the particular person added.

To make sure, these drivers are a small minority of EV house owners nationwide. However the episode illustrates how the volatility of gas costs can complicate the equation when selecting between an electrical and a standard combustion-engine car. And given the upper sticker costs for EVs — which might price a minimum of $10,000 greater than the equal gas-powered automobile — that would tip the stability for some automobile consumers.

Blame pure fuel

New Englanders are seeing uniquely excessive EV charging prices as a result of the area at present has the best electrical energy costs within the nation. At about 28 cents per kilowatt-hour this fall, it is double the nationwide common. 

Sarcastically, it is the area’s dependence on fossil fuels that is pushing these prices larger. About 45% of New England’s electrical energy comes from methane fuel, in contrast with about 38% nationwide, whereas the gas has tripled in value since Russia invaded Ukraine a yr in the past. All of the area’s utilities are elevating their electrical energy charges, though the particular prices can range lots even inside a small space, WBUR reported this fall.

The spike in electrical energy charges lately led 90 native politicians to jot down to Massachusetts’ utility fee calling for aid. On the similar time, fuel costs within the space have fallen from over $5 a gallon this summer season to $3.40 right now.

“In a big portion of the nation, EVs are lots cheaper to drive,” stated Beia Spiller, director of the transportation program at Assets for the Future (RFF), a clean-energy assume tank. “It actually, actually is determined by the situation.” 

RFF lately analyzed automobile possession knowledge in Massachusetts and located that, a minimum of by way of 2020, it price about twice as a lot on a per-mile foundation to drive a gasoline-fueled automobile than an EV.  

Whereas electrical energy costs have gone up lately due to international occasions, traditionally, “gasoline costs are way more variable,” she famous. “You don’t have any thought if there’s going to be a conflict someplace and abruptly you are paying $5 to $6 a gallon for gasoline costs.”

Different components affecting prices

The tradeoff between electrical and fuel will not be solely based mostly on somebody’s location (and the way a lot totally different fuels price to them), but in addition based mostly on the automobile. 

As an example, muscle automobiles and SUVs will virtually all the time be cheaper to function of their electrical variations. So will luxurious automobiles, based on a report from the Anderson Financial Group that estimated the price of fueling totally different automobile varieties. 

Common Motors president discusses new totally electrical Corvette and future of electrical autos


Christopher Hogan, a retired well being economist in northern Virginia, had his personal value shock when he and his spouse drove their Prius Prime to Ocean Metropolis, Maryland, final summer season. Hodge often runs the automobile on fuel for lengthy journeys, however this time “on a lark we discovered a station and determined to plug in,” Hogan stated. 

He was astonished to see the worth — $1.50 per kilowatt-hour — about 12 instances what he pays for electrical energy at house. “It is like these ATMs with a $15 charge,” he stated. 

Nonetheless, Hogan stated the expertise hasn’t turned him off his Prius. “I all the time thought it was hype — I did not care that a lot” about EVs, he stated. “However it’s so enjoyable. It pushes all my buttons. It is as handy as fuel automobiles, good for the atmosphere and it is enjoyable to drive.”

Hogan additionally stays a convert. Requested if he would take into account shopping for a standard automobile, he stated, “Not an opportunity. I might by no means purchase a non-hybrid automobile — that is depreciated know-how.”

Leave a Comment